Trevor Bright’s Thoughts On My Talk To Clacton and Holland Beach Hut Association

Trevor Bright heard by talk to Clacton and Holland Beach Hut Association and emailed me his thoughts.

I have posted Trevor’s emails before.  As Trevor used to be a project engineer with BP. I think we should take his views seriously, especially when it comes to using old oil rigs as reefs – the so call “rigs to reefs” scheme.

Dear Jeremy,

I enjoyed your talk at the Beach Hut Association meeting on Saturday.

1) Groyne Repairs
What I think is interesting about the table of costs for groyne repairs
is that after spending the £12k in 2009/10 at Holland on Sea that it
was realised that spending thousands was not the answer anymore and that
it is going to take millions to repair the groynes.
Your photographs clearly show that the groynes need to be above
sea level height and of course it is not just a case of replacing
the 'boards' that have gone missing but that beach recharge will be
required otherwise the force of the sea on a fully refurbished groyne
will just push it over. 

2) Funding
I cannot understand for the life of my why there is a problem in
obtaining funding. Mr Carswell keeps on about finding a pot of money
but, all we need, is an advance on the funds that it will be necessary
to be spend over the next 5 to 10 years. It is of course interesting to
note that on page 18 of the Royal Haskoning report it states 

'In some areas short sections of defence would begin to fail
over the
next 5 years'. This being so it can be expected that the £1.5m to £2m currently being spent per year by the council will increase exponentially. 3) Rigs to Reefs I am dubious about this as at present the Oil companies are responsible for abandonment of their offshore platforms and are obligated to return the seabed to it's original state (the same goes for the offshore wind farms?). I therefore do not see that it will be possible to remove a platform from one location, clean it and then cut it up and dump it in another location. This I think would need a change to legislation which is something we do not have time for. There was a lot of fuss in 1991 when the government allowed Shell to dispose of the Brent Spar in deep Atlantic waters (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brent_Spar) If I was cynical I could say that this was a political move to assist the offshore wind farm companies so that they will not have to carry out the full abandonment procedure. Anyway I have ranted enough. Best Regards Trevor

The Royal Haskoning report Trevor mentions is contained within the report of TDC March 2012 Cabinet, which you can download and read, though it’s 170 pages!

I especially like the second to last paragraph of page 81 of Royal Haskoning report where it talks about realigning (i.e. managed realiging = knocking hole in sea wall and flooding land) what it calls Defences W, X and Y.  Though it notes either the Boating Club would have to be relocated or it would be lost!

Just to be clear they are talking about the “Boating Club” at Holland Haven.  There is cliff here which runs from the slipway just to the south of Boating Club to just north of the radar tower.  This cliff is probably 20 feet above the sea wall and Royal Haskoning are talking about removing it so the sea can flood the land behind.

Someone appears to have lost the plot here and I don’t think it’s me.

What do you think?

This entry was posted in Beaches, Breakwaters, Groynes and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Trevor Bright’s Thoughts On My Talk To Clacton and Holland Beach Hut Association

  1. Jeremy says:

    And my reply to Trevor was

    Dear Trevor

    thanks for your email especially the compliments!

    I think the annual groyne maintenance ran to a few boards here and there
    I was a bit disingenous as the 12k related to about 10 groynes at Holland Haven
    not the entire 5.5km from pier to Haven

    In addition the cost must include repairds to sea wall
    as this is by now urgent.
    If diggers can fall through perhaps people will soon

    Mott MacDonald said they plan to start at Holland Haven

    I don’t know what Douglas was smoking but
    Neil Stock was a fan of rigs to reefs

    I’ve sent Douglas an email pointing out these things
    and in particular why he said there was no money from central government
    as I had just said EA have £40million in budget for clacton and holland for 12/13

    In any case there is money in EA budget, billions of it.
    They just want to spend it on managed realignment and
    habitat relocation for reasons of religous zealotry

    cheers

    Jeremy

  2. WIND INFO says:

    Nice Post for all readers. http://thecoastal-life.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

HTML tags are not allowed.

264,745 Spambots Blocked by Simple Comments

Anti-Spam Quiz:

CommentLuv badge